8
minute read
Mar 11, 2025

Improving Credit Risk Assessment Transparency for Lenders

Learn how increased transparency and explainability in lending decisions can help improve compliance, customer trust and efficiency.

Financial institutions are under increasing pressure to improve transparency in credit risk assessment. Regulatory bodies such as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) are increasing scrutiny on credit decisions, particularly regarding fairness, explainability, and compliance with consumer protection laws. The Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) mandates that lenders provide specific reasons for adverse credit decisions, and the CFPB has signaled that AI-driven lending models must be explainable to prevent unintentional bias. At the same time, customer expectations are evolving—borrowers want greater insight into how their creditworthiness is determined.

As part of our commitment to explainability in our modern credit risk assessment and lending solution, at Carrington Labs we implement refined frameworks and methodologies when using  artificial intelligence (AI) to empower financial institutions with accurate, holistic and transparent insights around credit risk.

In this article, we’ll explore how we’ve enabled one lender’s customer support teams to clearly and accurately explain changes in a borrower’s credit risk score, improving both transparency and borrower trust.

The Challenge of Explaining Credit Risk Assessments

One of our clients, a fintech offering short-term financial products, determines borrowers’ lending limits using a proprietary credit risk score. This credit risk score is built using modern credit risk modeling techniques, including machine learning. 

A frequent customer inquiry they receive is: “Why has my borrowing limit changed?” 

The answer often lies in shifts within the credit risk score, influenced by transaction history, bank account profile, and repayment behavior on previous loans with the lender.

However, it can be difficult for customer support agents to provide a concise yet informative response to inquiries about credit risk score changes. This is because many factors contribute to credit risk score, not always in a univariate and linear manner. Although the data sources driving the credit risk scores are clear, without clear explanations of credit risk score changes, customers may feel frustrated or confused about changes to their borrowing eligibility.

Improving Credit Risk Score Transparency with Explainability

The explainability built into Carrington Labs' AI-powered models has empowered support agents with structured, data-driven insights that they can easily communicate to customers. 

Our framework applies deliberate use of advanced analytical methods, as well as large language models, to analyze credit risk score changes by comparing the credit risk score between two points in time, identify key factors driving credit risk score fluctuations, and generate clear, structured explanations in simple language for the support agent. This allows support agents to confidently provide customers with accurate, transparent reasons for shifts in their creditworthiness.

How it works

  1. SHAP Value Computation at run time: SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) values measure the contribution of each financial behavior to the overall credit risk score change. For example, a significant drop in account balance might decrease a score by 50 points, whereas a recent late payment could reduce it by 30 points. This ensures a clear, quantifiable breakdown of the score adjustment. Whenever a credit risk score is calculated, the SHAP values and input feature values are added to audit logs. 
  2. Data Retrieval: When a support agent queries the reason for a risk score change, the system pulls historical audit logs for a customer’s credit risk score from two selected dates.
  3. Feature Analysis: The system evaluates financial behaviors such as spending patterns, income stability, and recent credit history. Each factor is assigned a relative importance score based on historical data correlations, helping identify the most influential drivers of score changes.
  4. Natural Language Generation: The system translates these complex statistical findings into a straightforward summary for support agents.

Summary of contribution of each input to the score change:

Example: Applying Transparent Credit Risk Explanations in the Real-World

Consider a hypothetical scenario based on the above challenge faced by our fintech client. 

A support agent receives an inquiry from a customer about their decreased borrowing capacity. 

On reviewing the customer’s profile, the support agent is presented with the following information: 

  • Customer ID: 12345
  • On November 22, 2024
    • Credit Risk Score: 569
    • Available Credit Limit: $500
  • On December 22, 2024:
    • Credit Risk Score: 219
    • Available Credit Limit: $100

By following the steps above, the lender is able to create a structured, data-driven explanation that support agents can easily communicate. 

For the above customer, the support agent is provided with the following explanation: 

"The customer’s risk score has decreased from 569 to 219 due to several financial behaviors. The primary reasons for this limit reduce are:

  • A significant drop in account balance, reducing available funds for loan repayment.
  • Increased transaction frequency, indicating higher spending behavior.
  • Recent late payments, which negatively impacted their creditworthiness.

Conversely, some factors helped stabilize the risk score:

  • Regular salary deposits continued, demonstrating a consistent income source.
  • No new large credit transactions, indicating controlled borrowing behavior."

With this explanation, support agents can confidently answer customer inquiries, reducing uncertainty and frustration while improving credit risk assessment transparency and borrower trust.

How AI Explainability Supports Compliance

In the U.S. financial landscape, regulatory bodies such as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) emphasize the importance of explainability in credit decisions. The increased scrutiny around AI-driven lending models underscores the need for transparency in credit risk assessment processes.

Carrington Labs prioritizes explainability in credit risk models. By integrating machine learning, explainable AI, and natural language generation, we have transformed risk score explanations from opaque calculations into actionable insights. This approach helps lenders improve credit decision transparency with clear, customer-friendly explanations that support compliance and trust. 

Key benefits of this approach include:

  • Regulatory Alignment: Ensuring compliance with evolving guidelines on AI transparency and consumer protection.
  • Operational Efficiency: Reducing the burden on support teams by providing structured, automated explanations. Agents no longer need to manually interpret data, reducing response times.
  • Customer Confidence: Customers gain a clear understanding of why their borrowing eligibility has changed, leading to improved financial decision-making and trust. 

The Future of Credit Risk Assessments

As the financial industry continues to evolve, the demand for transparent and explainable credit risk models will only grow. Lenders who adopt these frameworks now will be better positioned to navigate regulatory changes and build stronger relationships with their customers. 

Carrington Labs remains at the forefront of this shift, ensuring that advanced analytics empower lenders with clarity, compliance, and confidence in their credit risk assessments.

Financial institutions seeking to improve credit decision transparency can leverage Carrington Labs' expertise to ensure compliance and build borrower trust.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Financial institutions face increasing pressure to provide transparent explanations for credit decisions, driven by both customer expectations and regulatory requirements.
  2. Carrington Labs' explainability framework unlocks the ability for financial institutions, from banks to fintechs, to clearly communicate the reasons behind credit risk score changes, making complex financial assessments more accessible and transparent.
  3. Implementing explainability in AI and lending models not only improves customer trust but also aligns with regulatory trends emphasizing fairness and transparency in financial services.

As regulations tighten and customer expectations shift, now is the time for lenders to embrace explainable AI in their credit risk assessment processes.

 

Carrington Labs is here to help—reach out to our team to explore how explainability can strengthen your lending strategy.

CONTACT US